CLINICAL SUPERVISION IN NURSING PRACTICE: A COMPARATIVE STUDY IN PORTUGAL AND THE UNITED KINGDOM
Resumo
This research examines the practice of clinical supervision in nursing in both The United Kingdom and Portugal, one important pilar of safety care. The study was funded by the British Council under the Treaty of Windsor scheme. Forty five nurses from both countries completed questionnaires. One focus group interview was held in both countries involving three participants, six in total (only three volunteered) who had also completed the questionnaire. The quantitative data from the questionnaires were analysed using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences and the qualitative data from both the questionnaires and the focus groups were analysed using Colaizzi’s (1978) framework. The findings suggest that clinical supervision has positive benefits for professional development of nurses and their clinical practice. Constraints are evident, particularly in The United Kingdom and these included lack of time, lack of understanding of clinical supervision and lack of commitment.Implications for Nursing Management: Managers need to support clinical supervision for it is important for quality care and evidence based practice.Protocols for clinical supervision practice would enable managers to lead and support staff’s professional development and help to ensure quality care within the organisation.
Referências
Department of Health. Continuing Professional
Development: Quality in the new NHS. HSC 99/154. London.
DH;1999.
Department of Health. The New NHS: A first class service.
HSC 98/113. London. DH; 2009.
Walley P, Silvester K, Mountford S. Health-care process
improvement decisions: a systems perspective. International
Journal Of Health Care Quality Assurance. 2006; 19 (1):93-
National Health Service. NHS Leadership Qualities
Framework. London: Institute for Innovation and
Improvement - NHS; 2004.
Sales I, Pagani R. A preceptoria de território na Estratégia
de Saúde da Família em Sobral (CE). Sanare. 2004; (1):41-46
Abreu W. Education in clinical settings: theories, concepts
and didactic considerations. Coimbra: Formasau; 2007
Phillips J. Knowledge is power: using nursing information
management and leadership interventions to improve
services to patients, clients and users. Journal of Nursing
Management. 2005; 13(6):524-536.
Department of Health. The Operating Framework for the
NHS in England. London. DH; 2008.
Department of Health. High Quality Care for All. London.
DH; 2008.
Department of Health. Inspiring Leaders; leadership
for quality: Guidance for NHS talent and Leadership Plans.
London. DH; 2009.
Barros P, Simões J. Portugal - Health system review.
Health Systems in Transition. 2007; 9(5):1-140.
Proctor B. Supervision: a co-operative exercise in
accountability, In M. Marken and M.Payne (eds) Enabling and
Ensuring. Leicester: National Youth Bureau for Education in
Youth and Community Work; 1987.
Berg A, Hansson U. Dementia care nurses experiences
of systematic clinical group supervision and supervised
planned nursing care. Journal of Nursing Management. 2000;
(6):357-368.
Teasdale K, Brocklehurst N, Thorn N. Clinical supervision
and support for nurses: an evaluation study. Journal of
Advanced Nursing. 2001; 33(2):216-224.
Marrow CE. Clinical supervision in action: problems and
dilemmas [thesis]. Lancaster (UK): Lancaster University;
Heron J. Helping the Client: A Creative Practical Guide.
London: Sage Pub; 1990.
Ribeiro L, Andrade L. A enfermagem e a construção de
novos saberes e práticas a partir da estratégia saúde da
família. Sanare. 2004; 5(1):101-112
Buus N, Gonge H. Empirical studies of clinical supervision
in psychiatric nursing: a systematic review of the literature
and methodological critique. International Journal of Mental
Health Nursing. 2009; 18(4):250-64.
Maia P, Abreu W. Supervisão Clínica em Enfermagem: uma
abordagem centrada na reflexão, formação e qualidade das
práticas (Relatório – síntese do projecto de intervenção).
Porto: s.l.; 2003.
Varandas L. Continuing education and supervision of
clinical practices: an ecological perspective (Thesis). Aveiro:
University of Aveiro; 2008.
Cutliffe JR, Lowe L. A comparison of North American and
European conceptualizations of clinical supervision. Issues
in Mental Health Nursing. 2005; 26(5). 475-88.
Collaizi PF. Psychological research as the phenomenologist
views it. In Valle RS, King M. Existential – phenomenological
alternatives for psychology. New York: Oxford University
Press; 1978.
Faugier J, Butterworth T. Clinical Supervsion: A Position
Paper. School of Nursing Studies. University of Manchester;
Marrow CE, MaCauley D, Crumbie A. Promoting
reflective practice through structured clinical supervision.
In: Transforming Nursing Through Reflective Practice
Conference. 1996 Jul 17-19; Robinson College Cambridge;
Cambridge (UK); 1996.